Red Teaming - Adversarial Security Testing
About 2 min read
A red team is a specialized team that examines an organization's security posture from an attacker's perspective. It combines the methods that real attackers use - social engineering, physical intrusion, and technical exploits - to test in a realistic manner how far the organization's defenses actually hold up. Originating in military exercises, this concept has spread widely across the field of cybersecurity since the 2000s, and regular exercises are conducted primarily by financial institutions and critical infrastructure operators.
The Difference from Penetration Testing
Red team exercises are often confused with penetration testing, but they differ greatly in objective, scope, and duration.
| Aspect | Penetration Testing | Red Team Exercise |
|---|---|---|
| Objective | Finding technical vulnerabilities | Evaluating the defensive capability of the entire organization |
| Scope | Specific systems or networks | The entire organization (people, processes, technology) |
| Duration | 1 - 4 weeks | Several weeks to several months |
| Methods | Mainly technical testing | Also includes social engineering and physical intrusion |
| Defenders' awareness | Often notified in advance | Only a few executives are aware |
| Deliverables | A list of vulnerabilities and remediation proposals | Attack scenarios and organizational improvement proposals |
The Relationship Between Red, Blue, and Purple Teams
Imitates attackers and exploits gaps in the defenses. Achieving the objective without being detected is the criterion for success.
The SOC and incident response teams fall into this category. They are responsible for detecting, containing, and recovering from attacks.
A collaborative approach in which the red and blue teams share their insights to continuously improve defensive capabilities.
Leveraging the MITRE ATT&CK Framework
In modern red team exercises, the MITRE ATT&CK framework functions as a common language. ATT&CK systematizes the tactics and techniques that real attackers use, and red teams design attack scenarios from the ATT&CK matrix when formulating their exercise plans. By also using ATT&CK IDs in post-exercise reports, the blue team can quantitatively evaluate which specific techniques it lacks the ability to detect. By combining it with threat intelligence, it becomes possible to run exercises focused on the techniques that the attack groups targeting your organization actually use.
The Typical Flow of a Red Team Exercise
Before the exercise begins, it is essential to clearly define the "Rules of Engagement." Systems out of scope, the range of permitted attack methods, emergency contacts, and so on are documented and approved by management. Omitting this step risks the exercise being mistaken for an actual incident or causing unintended disruptions to business systems.
Cost-Effectiveness and Frequency
The cost of a full-scale red team exercise, depending on its size and duration, ranges from several million to tens of millions of yen. Because it costs several times more than penetration testing, not every organization can conduct one every year. As a general guideline, financial institutions and critical infrastructure operators are recommended to run one once a year, and other companies once every 2 - 3 years. Between exercises, it is realistic to supplement with penetration testing and vulnerability scanning.red team security books on Amazon are also a useful reference.
Common Misconceptions
The notion that "if a red team exercise fails to break in, you are safe" is dangerous. Because the exercise is conducted within a limited time and budget, a failure to break in merely means that "we could not break in with those methods." Real attackers can try every possible means with no time limit.
To maximize the results of a red team exercise, it is important to position it as part of a comprehensive security program combined with insider threat countermeasures and a security checklist. As a means of verifying the effectiveness of a corporate password policy, a red team exercise is also extremely effective.
Was this article helpful?